A delivery rider in Singapore has lost his bid for $500 monthly maintenance from his ex-wife following an injury that left him blind in one eye. The case, heard in a local court, centered on the ex-wife’s refusal to provide financial support, citing the rider’s physical condition as a reason.

The rider, identified only by his name Toh Yong Chuan, sustained the injury during a work-related incident. Legal documents show he had previously sought maintenance payments, arguing that his reduced earning capacity justified ongoing support. However, the court ruled that the injury did not meet the threshold for continued financial assistance.

This is not the first time Toh has faced legal challenges over maintenance. Earlier this year, he was involved in a dispute over child custody, which further complicated his financial situation. The court emphasized that maintenance decisions are based on the recipient’s current needs and the payer’s ability to contribute.

Maintenance claims in Singapore are typically assessed based on income, living standards, and the relationship between the parties. In this case, the ex-wife’s legal team argued that Toh’s ability to work had not been permanently impaired, and that he could still support himself. The court agreed, dismissing the request.

The case highlights the complexities of maintenance law in Singapore, where personal circumstances and legal precedents play a key role in determining outcomes. Legal experts note that injuries affecting earning capacity are closely scrutinized, and the burden of proof lies with the claimant.